| Ashtyn Allen |
2019 |
Hartwick College |
Girls Track |
| JJ Babcock |
2022 |
Elmira College |
Boys Basketball |
| Aaron Barry |
2016 |
Misericordia University |
Football |
| Gavin Bradley |
2022 |
Castleton State College |
Wrestling |
| Nate Bradley |
2018 |
Rochester Institute of Technology |
Wrestling |
| Grace Cobb |
2024 |
Wilkes University |
Girls Swimming |
| Evan Cooper |
2024 |
Virginia Wesleyan College |
Boys Golf |
| Asher Ellis |
2022 |
Elmira College |
Boys Soccer |
| Taylar Fisher |
2023 |
Misericordia University |
Girls Swimming |
| Chris Horton |
2018 |
Rochester Institute of Technology |
Wrestling |
| Mitch Kerrick |
2017 |
College of Brockport, State University of New York |
Football |
| Lucas Kraft |
2023 |
Elmira College |
Baseball |
| Aaron Lane |
2020 |
Elmira College |
Boys Basketball |
| Mason Lister |
2023 |
St. John Fisher College |
Football |
| Amelia Martin |
0 |
Elmira College |
Volleyball |
| Amelia Martin |
0 |
Elmira College |
Softball |
| Kayleigh Miller |
2021 |
Pennsylvania College of Technology |
Girls Basketball |
| Jenny Ryan |
2023 |
Muhlenberg College |
Volleyball |
| David Scheftic |
2020 |
Penn State University, Erie |
Boys Soccer |
| Harley Sullivan |
2021 |
King's College (Pennsylvania) |
Softball |
| Ally Thoman |
2023 |
College of Brockport, State University of New York |
Girls Soccer |
| Jon Vough |
2018 |
Alvernia University |
Wrestling |
| Vaughn Wagnecz |
2022 |
Hartwick College |
Football |
| Sean Waltman |
2018 |
Hartwick College |
Boys Track |
| Taegan Williams |
2023 |
Misericordia University |
Girls Swimming |
